All stories

News

Nightshirt vs Pyjamas: Which Is Better for Men? | Nightcut

Nightshirt vs Pyjamas: Which Is Better for Men? | Nightcut

Nightshirt or pyjamas?

Why more men are making the switch.

Pyjamas have had a good run. For most of the last century they were what a well-dressed man wore to bed, and the matching set still turns up every Christmas.

But ask most men what they actually sleep in and the answer is an old T-shirt. Pyjamas, it turns out, are something men own rather than wear. The nightshirt is the quieter option, and it’s worth a fair hearing.

The waistband question.

The biggest difference is the one you feel first. Pyjamas come in two pieces, so there’s always a waistband, and a waistband is the thing that twists, digs and rides up overnight.

A nightshirt is one piece. Ours falls from a dropped shoulder to a hem at the knee, with side splits so it moves when you do. Nothing ties, nothing pulls at the middle, and nothing needs hitching up when you get out of bed.

Cooler, by design.

Pyjama trousers cover the legs all night, which is fine in January and less fine the rest of the year. A nightshirt leaves room for air to move, and in 100% cotton poplin, the crisp plain-weave cloth of a classic shirt, it stays cool rather than clammy.

If you’re the one who kicks the covers off by two in the morning, this is the point that will matter most.

Easier at both ends of the day.

One piece means one thing to put on. Pull it over your head at night, and in the morning it’s already fit to be seen: answering the door, making the coffee, reading the paper with the sleeves rolled. Pyjamas tend to look slept in by breakfast. A good nightshirt looks like a shirt.

The look.

This is where pyjamas struggle. Too often a grown man in a matching set looks either twelve or ninety, and a nightshirt from the wrong shop does no better.

Done properly, a nightshirt is simply a better-looking thing to sleep in. A Nehru collar keeps the neckline clean, the length is generous without being theatrical, and the prints do the rest: a deep navy stripe for late nights, a white and blue stripe for slow mornings, or a forest green panther for a little more swagger.

When pyjamas still win.

To be fair to them: if your bedroom is properly cold, or you want your legs covered for a draughty house, pyjama trousers do that job well. Plenty of men keep both, and reach for the nightshirt for most of the year.

Making the switch.

If you’re trying a nightshirt for the first time, take your usual size for a loose fit, or size down for a closer cut. There are two sizes, S/M and L/XL, and three prints, at £90 each.

Give it a week. Most men don’t go back.

The Vesper Collection

Shop the story

News

More stories